Traverse the article
Leading the world in the Open Banking revolution, the UK gives customers unparalleled access to their financial data while stimulating a wave of fintech innovation. Because of the safe exchange of financial data, we have witnessed the emergence of intelligent budgeting applications, smooth account aggregation, and customised financial management solutions. Consumers, however, are calling for more dynamic and customised services that can adjust to their ever-changing needs as the financial landscape shifts regularly.
This need and technical innovation have paved for the next chapter in open finance. The Financial Conduct Authority has announced its strategy for this transition, emphasising the importance of Variable Recurring Payments in realising the full potential of open finance. Let us explore how such payments are expected to change the financial scene and create a more effective financial system.
Understanding Variable Recurring Payments: Beyond Fixed Recurring Payments
Consider a world in which your bills adjust automatically based on your real usage, your savings contributions vary with your income, and maintaining subscriptions becomes simple. This is the promise of variable recurring payments. They represent an important shift in our understanding of recurrent transactions, moving away from the rigidity of fixed payments and towards a more dynamic, adaptive paradigm.
Defining Variable Recurring Payments
Variable Recurring Payments (VRP) is an authorisation you give to a third-party provider to make periodic payments on your behalf, with one important difference: the amount of each payment is variable. Consider giving someone permission to automatically pay your utility bill, but the amount they withdraw each month is determined by your usage. This dynamic nature is what distinguishes VRPs and opens up a world of new possibilities.
VRPs can provide intriguing opportunities for personal financial management. Consider a savings app that regulates your contributions based on your income, ensuring you constantly save a comfortable amount without exceeding your budget. Likewise, imagine a budgeting tool that utilises VRPs to dynamically allocate funds to different categories, ensuring you always have enough for essentials while also allowing for some discretionary expenditure.
The versatility of VRPs extends to businesses too. Think of a subscription service that automatically modifies its price based on the services used, or a loan repayment plan that responds to a company’s changing revenue streams.
Types of Variable Recurring Payments
There are two kinds of Variable Recuring Payments:
- Sweeping: This method automatically transfers money between accounts with the same name at other banks. Also known as Me-to-me type.
- Non-Sweeping: Used for commercial purposes. Payments are to made to merchants or accounts under a different name.
Implementation of sweeping VRPs has been sluggish, despite the Competition and Markets Authority’s (2021) mandate for the UK’s top banks. The payments industry is discussing progressively about the opportunities that non-sweeping VRPs offer, even if they are not yet regulated.
Fixed Recurring Payments Vs Variable Recurring Payments
| Feature | Fixed Recurring Payments (FRPs) | Variable Recurring Payments (VRPs) |
| Payment Amount | Fixed and predetermined | Variable, based on pre-agreed criteria |
| Control | Limited control over individual payments | Greater control; adjustments possible |
| Flexibility | Inflexible; requires manual changes | Highly flexible; adapts automatically |
| Use Cases | Subscriptions with fixed fees, loan repayments | Utility bills, usage-based subscriptions, personalised insurance, dynamic savings |
| Example | Monthly gym membership with a set fee | Electricity bill based on consumption |
Variable Recurring Payments Systems Technical Build: Key Technologies
Open Banking APIs
- At the heart of VRPs are open banking APIs
- Serve as gateway for third-party providers to access customer bank accounts securely.
- Enable seamless initiation of payments and integration of financial ecosystem.
- Enhance user experience by simplifying payment flows and empowering control over financial transactions.
OAuth 2.0 Authentication
- Enhances security during transactions by allowing users to grant third-party applications seamless access to their data while protecting sensitive information.
- On customer’s consent, access tokens are generated.
- Enables third-party providers to initiate payments on behalf of the user without repeated authentication.
REST APIs
- Facilitate real-time data exchange between stakeholders, such as FIs, payment processors, and third-party providers.
- Manage VRP sessions and ensure automatic payment triggering.
- Support asynchronous communication, enable faster interactions and improved performance.
Encryption and Secure Data Transmission
- Essential components of the VRP framework.
- Protocols like Transport Layer Security (TLS) safeguard sensitive payment and account data.
- Compliance with the Revised Payment Services Directive mandates qualified electronic signatures through eIDAS certificates for Strong Customer Authentication.
- Protects individual identities and fortifies and transaction security against potential fraud.
Key Players in Variable Recurring payments Implementation
Banks as Enablers
- Provide secure and dependable APIs that allow TPPs to access customer accounts and initiate VRP transactions.
- Ensure that VRP functionality is seamlessly integrated with existing systems and platforms.
- Prioritise data security and privacy, establishing strong security measures and guaranteeing compliance with data protection regulations.
TPPs as Innovators
Leveraging VRP capabilities to create innovative solutions, like
- Developing personalised budgeting tools and AI-driven financial assistants.
- Offering subscription management platforms and dynamic insurance solutions.
- Driving competition and innovation within the financial market.
- Offering consumers greater choice and access to a wider range of financial products and services.
Collaboration is a Key
Effective collaboration between banks, TPPs, regulators, and customers is necessary to successfully adopt VRPs in the UK. Clear APIs must be made available by banks, TPPs must guarantee compatibility, regulations must be set, and consumers must be informed of the pros and cons of VRPs. This collaborative ecosystem has the potential to make the financial environment more dynamic, personalised, and consumer centric.
How Variable Recurring Payments Work in Reality
UK's Regulatory Framework for Variable Recurring Payments
- The UK’s VRPs are governed by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) Order and the Payment Services Regulations (PSRs).
- The CMA Order mandates VRPs for sweeping transactions, only applicable to designated banks.
- Account Servicing Payment Service Providers (ASPSPs) outside the CMA9 are not obligated to allow PISPs access to VRP APIs for non-sweeping applications.
- VRP transactions are classified as a regulated payment service under the PSRs, requiring only authorised PISPs to initiate payments.
- Payment service providers must apply strong customer authentication when a payer initiates an electronic payment transaction.
- ASPSPs can either use exemptions for low-risk transactions or delegate SCA responsibility to the PISP.
Important Use Cases of Variable Recurring Payments
- Personalised Insurance: Consider automobile insurance premiums that vary according to your actual driving behaviour. VRPs enable telematics-driven insurance, in which safe driving practices result in cheaper premiums that are immediately adjusted using VRPs. Similarly, health or life insurance policies could be tailored based on activity tracker data or lifestyle preferences.
- Income-Based Spending and Saving: Freelancers and gig workers with variable salaries can profit greatly. VRPs can automate savings contributions, modifying them based on monthly earnings. Investment contributions can also be dynamically changed, maximising profits during high-income periods and reducing contributions during low-income years.
- E-commerce: By removing the need to provide any personal/sensitive data, VRPs make payments safer for both customers and retailers. In order to reduce friction and maintain control over their spending, consumers can also set maximum spending restrictions and pay for everything that falls below them with just one tap.
- Payment of Taxes: businesses can prevent cash flow issues and guarantee timely submissions by using VRPs to automate tax-related payments like income tax or VAT. Small firms, for example, can utilise VRPs to auto-set funds for monthly tax payments, so as to never miss a deadline and optime cash flow management.
- Subscription Payments: In contrast to cards, bank account information does not expire. Furthermore, Strong client Authentication occurs just once, when the client first activates the VRP, reducing the possibility of payment failures due to technical issues. VRPs make it easier to manage spending and cancel subscriptions, which improves the user experience. Customers can establish spending alert criteria and cancel subscriptions straight from their banking app.
- Delivery and Taxi Services: For food delivery and taxi services, VRPs improve the entire payment interaction by expediting the procedure and providing greater convenience for both customers and riders. For example, companies such as Uber and Uber Eats can use VRPs to dynamically alter prices based on travel distance or time frame and also implement periodic meal delivery. This reduces transaction fees when compared to typical card-based payments.
- Utility Bills: Bills for electricity, water and gas often change. VRPs automate these payments and alter the amount based on actual consumption. This avoids manual payments and prevents overpayments or underpayments.
- Flexible Credit Repayments: VRPs can adjust loan repayments to reflect fluctuating revenue. If your income decreases, your repayment amount can automatically change thus preventing missed payments and financial burden.
- Variable Price Retail: Consider an outlet store that modifies its prices dependent on demand or time of day. VRPs might easily facilitate these trades.
- Shared Expense Splitting: Easily split bills or share expenditures with friends or roommates. VRPs automate payment collection, eliminating the unpleasantness of following up with individuals.
- Automated Parking Payments: VRPs can do away with the requirement to estimate and pay in advance by automating parking payments based on real time parked.
- Flexible Charitable Giving: Configure recurring charitable contributions that change according to your spending plan or certain events. For instance, each time your favourite sports team wins, give a little donation.
Benefits of Variable Recurring Payments
For Customers
- Freedom from Rigid Schedules: Consumers get more control over their money by altering payment amounts to reflect changing circumstances (e.g., income variations, unanticipated spending).
- Personalised Payment Plans: Customise payment plans to meet individual requirements and financial goals, such as increasing savings during periods of higher income or cutting expenses during times of financial stress.
- Prevent Overdrafts: Avoid costly overdraft fees by making payments only when there are enough cash available.
- Optimise Spending: Make smart spending decisions using real-time data and modify payments accordingly.
- Relief from Card Updates: Imagine being able to switch to a new debit card without having to update your card information across several services, as VRPs handle maintaining your payments on schedule.
- Clearer Understanding of Payments: Gain a better understanding of payment amounts and the reasons for any variations.
- Time Savings: Automate routine payment procedures to free up time and mental bandwidth.
- Lower Financial Pressure: Lower the likelihood of missing payments and late fees, resulting in a more calm and stress-free financial experience.
- Encourage Sustainable Spending Habits: Motivate responsible spending and saving by matching payments to actual needs and income.
For Business
- Reduced Fees & Higher Profits: VRPs offer a cost-effective alternative to traditional card payments, reducing transaction costs and allowing businesses with high transaction volumes to save more money.
- Improved Security and Smarter Payments: VRPs eliminate the need for shops to maintain sensitive card information, lowering the risk of data breaches. Furthermore, VRP transactions are protected by Strong Customer Authentication (SCA), ensuring strong security for both enterprises and consumers.
- Improved Customer Relationships: Provide more flexible and personalised payment choices that are tailored to particular consumer needs.
- More Reliable Revenue Streams: Remove the uncertainty associated with typical recurring payments, resulting in more predictable cash flow.
- Optimise Pricing Strategies: Leverage dynamic pricing models to alter rates based on usage, demand, and customer behaviour.
Navigating the Challenges
Data Security and Privacy
For VRPs to safeguard customer information against digital threats like fraud and data breaches, strong security measures are essential. These consist of stringent security audits, multi-factor authentication, and robust encryption. Consumer control over their data depends on adherence to data privacy laws like the GDPR. Trust is increased by having transparent and unambiguous data privacy policies. It is also crucial to put strong fraud detection and prevention measures in place, such as keeping an eye on suspicious activity and offering resources for reporting fraudulent transactions.
Putting Consumers First
Consumer protection in VRPs requires clear communication, robust frameworks, and financial inclusion. Consumers should understand VRPs’ operations, payment calculations, authorisation management, and rights. A robust framework should set payment limits, allow cooling-off periods, provide dispute resolution mechanisms, and ensure VRPs are accessible to all consumers, including those with limited digital literacy or vulnerable to financial exploitation.
The Regulators’ Role
Regulators play an important role in directing responsible innovation in the changing regulatory landscape by providing clear and simple policies that promote innovation and consumer protection. They must work together with industry stakeholders to create effective regulatory frameworks and encourage sustainable innovation, while prioritising consumer interests through best practices, industry standards, and an innovative and collaborative culture.
The Future of Open Banking: A Variable Recurring Payments-Powered Ecosystem
Consider a world in which your funds adapt smoothly to your lifestyle. Where your subscriptions modify automatically based on consumption, your insurance premiums represent your unique risk profile, and your savings increase seamlessly in tandem with your income. This futuristic picture is not science fiction; it is becoming a reality as Variable Recurring Payments become more prevalent.
VRPs can change Open Banking from a data-driven system to one that actually strengthens users. By embracing this technology and cultivating a collaborative environment, we can create a future in which finance is really personalised, efficient, and empowering for everyone. This is a future in which your money works for you, not the other way around.
Final Thoughts
Variable Recurring Payments are more than just easy; they are a stimulus for innovation. Variable Recurring Payments are a key step towards the future of finance, providing a more seamless, intelligent, and user-centric financial experience for everyone in the UK. Yes! Embracing VRPs relieve us of the locks of traditional payment schedules, providing a more personalised and responsive financial experience.
Get started with Open Banking today
Tavas – Open Banking Product Suite and Solutions
